Travelling down the harbour line. Could that ever be bad? To ears untrained, this may sound like luxury, paradise almost. But to those millions travelling, within and alongside the train hugging down the Harbour Line in Mumbai, the imagery wouldn't quite be that of white sands, glistening water and milti-hued skies. Quite the contrary actually.
Broken tracks, crumbling houses, the stench of excreta and other undefinable odours, groups of men squatting on the dusty ground, sharing a beedi, playing a game of teen-patti (what they stake is unclear, really), women washing clothes, vessels and children in water that can hardly be called that. And the patter of feet climbing in and out of the train at Govandi (a suburban Mumbai station). Their game. a dangerous one. But then, what do they know about safety?
Although Mumbai has been home for a decade, I am a Calcuttan by birth. It is therefore my birthright to point a finger at Dominique Lapierre. To rave and rant at his audacity. Dare he paint a picture so grim, so dark, so true? Oh, white blood, you have no right. Would any of my own country men do such grave injustice to their own nation? I think not.
Then, at this juncture, I read what I'm writing. And wonder. Does poverty sell? Is it fair to say that we are at a level, closet sadists? Not quite correct terminology, since we're not all inflicting pain. But yes, we read about it. Heck, we write about it.
Would the lucre of Malabar Hill inspire me to dig out my notepad, and start scribbling furiously? Has not thus far.It is a strange world that makes us glorify rubbish heaps and abject hunger.
For most commuters, these sights are passe. It's called acclimitization. But it takes time to refrain from staring out the window and wincing at the sight of little children, scarcely clad, wandering down empty tracks, searching for food, shelter and security.
Oh Maslow, you may have a point.
I am new to commuting. These sights unnerve me. Not that I'm about to shed my capitalist garb, chuck up a high paying job and do great service for mankind by trying to heal the world.
Altruism is passe.
This is the new-age. I am a new-age woman. Give me my palm pilot, Nokia 8850 and watch me rule the world. My world.
Different from their world. The one I see passing by outside the window of my train. That would be unaware of the Microsoft trial, the Mauritian tax laws, Cronjegate or Ronaldo's injury.
They wait. For a miracle.
What stayed with you?
A line that lingered, a feeling, a disagreement. Great comments are as valuable as the original piece.
Responses3
The last line..'they wait for a miracle'- I think not. They don't wait for anything. They probably don't even know how 'deprived and pathetic' their life is. It is only for writers, critics and managers that their wretchedness exists. It is my belief that on an average these people experience the same quantum of joy, sorrow, contentment and despair as any cellphone-toting IIM grad.
They probably do not!! And it could also be said that they experience these emotions in a more intense manner - free of the sterility of civilized life. However I am curious how you reached that conclusion? Where doth the belief come from? Have you a lived a life of a tramp, a homeless or a wretched ( for whatever that means) soul? Or is it just another writer upholding the cause of the downtrodden? Heart2Heart
No, I haven't lived the life of a tramp. But one can only feel so depressed, so bored and so elated in life (again, my belief). Therefore, they can not possibly feel worse than I have at times, and probably not better either. One easy way to arrive at that conclusion is to look at those who're richer and grander than you- do you think that on an average they have more joys/sorrows/boredom than you? And then extrapolate.. And most of us have definitely observed poverty from close enough to understand it.
More by Abhilasha Khaitan
Catcher in the Rye
This is not a book review. Dont think it is within the realm of possibility (and my capability) to review the book I want to talk about, or its author for that matter. How do you review a book which m
Finally
Finally Posted by Abhilasha Khaitan on Friday January 07, @08:44AM Finally. Time to leave. Unexplored territory awaits. I should be excited. In fact, I am”.right? Well, it's tempered a mite, by t
The Most Beautiful Flower
Posted by Abhilasha Khaitan on Wednesday May 10, @12:59AM Borrowed from a forwarded mail. But a favourite. Really beautiful, so sharing it. Credit to: Cheryl L. Costello-Forshey The park bench was de
More Stories
Hirsute Pursuits
Hirsute Pursuits Schnozzle shearing I once nicked my nose while trying to shave a nose hair, which eluded the razor and swung back out from under the cartilage to stare me in the mirror, as if to say
The Burden of My Mind
Posted by Strider on Thursday June 01, @02:31AM Queen sang "too much love will kill u", and sometimes I feel too many expectations will kill me too. My life has become a struggle just trying to prov
SPACE,TIME AND TRUTH!!
SPACE,TIME AND TRUTH!! Posted by Aragorn on Tuesday June 05, @03:55PM Well i'm sure most of you will be familiar with quantum theory..hold it!! dont turn away at the sound of physics..this is not a